Which scales are better electronic or mechanical? Which floor scales are more accurate?

Each of us buys outdoor mechanical or electronic scales to take care of our figure, monitor the development of our child, for classes sports, etc. Having several weighing instruments on the farm is impractical, since many models combine the functions of a kitchen and a household instrument. Therefore, the choice of a weighing device is more practical than financial.

There are different scales on sale, and which scales are better electronic or simple mechanical - it is not always clear. You need to know the characteristics of each model, imagine why the scales are bought, how and where they will be operated, and most importantly - how much money you are willing to spend on this device. Consider all the questions in order.

Advantages and disadvantages of electronic scales

The main element of the electronic device is a semiconductor sensor paired with a plate of springy material. The force applied to the plate is detected by the sensor and converted into an electrical signal, which is processed by the microprocessor and displayed on the device. Modern floor scales have built-in computer programs that calculate the ratio of bone tissue, fats and muscles, store all weighing results in memory, and even give recommendations on changing loads or diet.

Advantages of electronic models:

1. High measurement accuracy - up to the sixth decimal place.
2. Extensive measurement range, reliability, wide auxiliary functionality.
3. Design can be any and does not depend on functionality.
4. The device is automatically set to zero.
5. Many electronic floor scales can display weighing results in different units: in pounds or kilograms.
6. Low error of result.
7. Small dimensions.
8. Digital display of the result.

Disadvantages:

1. There are risks of damaging the electronics.
2. Electronic scales of any class are designed for relatively light weight - often up to 150 kg, sometimes up to 220 kg.
3. It is necessary to periodically change the batteries - the device will show more accurately with a fresh battery.
4. High cost.

Characteristics of popular models of electronic scales

Zelmer BS 1800

1. Accuracy - 100 g.
2. The maximum weight is 150 kg.
3. Automatic on / off device.
4. Electronic memory for 8 users.
5. The case is made of tempered glass.
6. Case color - black / silver.
7. Warranty period - 2 years.

Sencor SBS 5021

1. Fat measurement: 4-60% (0.1% threshold).
2. Water measurement: 27.5-66% (0.1% threshold).
3. Measurement of muscle mass: 20-56% (threshold of 0.1%).
4. 5-level graphic display.
5. Ultra-thin case design, display.
6. Soft buttons.
7. The error is 100 grams.
8. The maximum weight is 150 kg.
9. Electronic memory for 12 users.

Beurer GS 207 Spring

1. Electronic scales with a platform of high-strength glass.
2. Platform: 30x30 cm.
3. Flat body 19 mm thick.
4. Enlarged display (digits height 40 mm).
5. Maximum weight: 150 kg.
6. Division price: 100 gr.
7. Congestion indicator.
8. Auto power on and off.

Advantages and disadvantages of mechanical scales

Mechanical scales work on the basis of compression-tension of the spring under pressure on the platform, so the weighing accuracy is much lower than that of electronic counterparts - the error can be up to 1 kg. Such a device is quite suitable for domestic use, but not for sports.

Advantages of mechanical models:

1. Low price, affordable to all consumers.
2. Using a mechanical device is much easier than electronic ones - just stand on the platform and look at the result.
3. Long term of operation.
4. Expanded range of measurements in comparison with the electronic device.
5. There is no power source and electronic filling, which makes the scales more reliable.

Disadvantages:

1. Lack of automatic tracking and storing of results.
2. High measurement error and low accuracy.
3. No helper options.
4. The need to set the arrow to zero each time.

Characteristics of popular models of mechanical scales

Camry BR2016

1. The maximum measured weight is 130 kg.
2. Price of one division: 1 kg.
3. Dimensions 24.3 x 26.8 x 4.2 cm.
4. An anti-slip coating is applied to the base.
5. Manual zero adjustment.

Camry BR9015A

1. The maximum measured weight is 130 kg.
2. Price of one division: 1 kg.
3. Dimensions 25.7 x 26.3 x 3.5 cm.
4. An anti-slip coating is applied to the base.
5. Manual zero adjustment.

A-Plus

1. Maximum weight: 130 kg.
2. The original design.
3. Division price: 1 kg.
4. Metric measurement system.
5. Weight: 2.3 kg
6. Dimensions: 350x350x60 mm

Which are better - mechanical or electronic

Analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of all types of scales, we come to the conclusion: mechanical scales are cheaper, but have a larger error. Well suited for normal weight control. If one person will use them, then the functions of storing the results are not needed, like other electronic options. Unpretentious in maintenance and use.

Electronic models are a complete control of all the necessary parameters, which is useful for athletes or diet-conscious people. Also this option is good for use in gyms or fitness clubs, as it allows you to remember data of a group of people.

There are certain rules that are recommended to use when choosing a purchase. Here they are:

Rule number 1: When choosing an apparatus, be sure to specify the main measuring system (Anglo-American or metric).

Rule number 2: Decide in advance where the scales will be installed. For rooms with high humidity (porch, bathroom), it is recommended to choose the appropriate housing protection. The surface of the device must be rubberized, corrugated or rough.

Rule number 3: The model must have devices for leveling the platform, and it is recommended to check the accuracy of the device before buying. This applies to both mechanical and electronic devices.

Rule number 4: Choose a display with large numbers. If the scales are mechanical - with a noticeable arrow and inscriptions.

Watch the program “Live Healthy” about the choice of floor scales:

A few extra pounds bother you? Do not rush to go on a diet: maybe your scales are lying. The operation of the mechanical unit is based on the compression of the spring, and it can stretch out over time. Therefore, do not be surprised if in a year the scales have to be changed to others, possibly electronic.